American Civil Liberties Union: on Drugs


ACLU: Drug testing for welfare is ineffective and unconstitutional

Drug testing welfare recipients as a condition of eligibility is a policy that is scientifically, fiscally, and constitutionally unsound. The 1996 Welfare Reform Act authorized--but did not require--states to impose mandatory drug testing as a condition of eligibility. No states currently [do so because]:
Source: ACLU 2015-16 voting recommendation on Welfare Weed Mar 2, 2012

ACLU: Drug prohibition means corruption, not an end to drug use

During the Civil War, morphine (an opium derivative and cousin of heroin) was found to have pain-killing properties and soon became the main ingredient in several patent medicines. In the late 19th century, marijuana and cocaine were put to various medicinal uses--marijuana to treat migraines; cocaine for chronic fatigue.

At the turn of the century, many drugs were made illegal when a mood of temperance swept the nation. In 1914, Congress banned opiates and cocaine. Alcohol prohibition quickly followed. That did not mean, however, an end to drug use. It meant that, suddenly, people were arrested and jailed for doing what they had previously done without government interference. Prohibition also meant the emergence of a black market, operated by criminals & marked by violence.

In 1933, because of concern over widespread organized crime & police corruption, alcohol prohibition was repealed. Meanwhile, federal prohibition of heroin and cocaine remained.

Source: ACLU 2017 voting recommendation on opioid crisis Feb 17, 2017

ACLU: A "drug free America" is not realistic; repeal prohibition

People in almost all cultures, in every era, have used psychoactive drugs. Native South Americans take coca-breaks the way we, in this country, take coffee-breaks. Native North Americans use peyote and tobacco in their religious ceremonies the way Europeans use wine. Alcohol is the drug of choice in Europe, the U.S. and Canada, while many Muslim countries tolerate the use of opium and marijuana.

A "drug free America" is not a realistic goal, and by criminally banning psychoactive drugs the government has ceded all control of potentially dangerous substances to criminals. Instead of trying to stamp out all drug use, our government should focus on reducing drug abuse and prohibition-generated crime. This requires a fundamental change in public policy: repeal of criminal prohibition and the creation of a reasonable regulatory system.

Source: ACLU 2017 voting recommendation on opioid crisis Feb 17, 2017

Carlos Lopez-Cantera: Require random, mandatory drug testing of state employees

HB 1205: Requires drug testing to be conducted within each state agency's appropriation; authorizes agencies within state government to require employees to submit to periodic random drug testing.

Analysis by ACLU Florida: The legislature took it upon itself to expand the Drug-Free Workplace Program to mandate random, suspicionless drug testing for state employees on a rotating basis. Each state agency can choose whether to participate in the program as it will have to find the funds to do so, i.e. pay for the drug tests, in its current allotted budget. If an employee fails the drug test, he/she must attend a rehab program or face disciplinary action or discharge.

Legislative Outcome: Passed House 79-37-3 on Mar/2/12; State Rep. Carlos Lopez-Cantera voted YES; Passed Senate 26-14-0 on Mar/9/12; Signed by Governor Rick Scott on Mar/19/12

Source: ACLU Analysis of Florida legislative voting record HB 1205 Mar 2, 2012

Darren Soto: Oppose mandatory drug testing of state employees

HB 1205: Requires drug testing to be conducted within each state agency's appropriation; authorizes agencies within state government to require employees to submit to periodic random drug testing.

Analysis by ACLU Florida: The legislature took it upon itself to expand the Drug-Free Workplace Program to mandate random, suspicionless drug testing for state employees on a rotating basis. Each state agency can choose whether to participate in the program as it will have to find the funds to do so, i.e. pay for the drug tests, in its current allotted budget. If an employee fails the drug test, he/she must attend a rehab program or face disciplinary action or discharge.

Legislative Outcome: Passed House 79-37-3 on Mar/2/12; Passed Senate 26-14-0 on Mar/9/12; State Senator Darren Soto voted YES: Signed by Governor Rick Scott on Mar/19/12

Source: ACLU Analysis of Florida legislative voting record HB 1205 Mar 9, 2012

Greg Steube: Require random, mandatory drug testing of state employees

HB 1205: Requires drug testing to be conducted within each state agency's appropriation; authorizes agencies within state government to require employees to submit to periodic random drug testing.

Analysis by ACLU Florida: The legislature took it upon itself to expand the Drug-Free Workplace Program to mandate random, suspicionless drug testing for state employees on a rotating basis. Each state agency can choose whether to participate in the program as it will have to find the funds to do so, i.e. pay for the drug tests, in its current allotted budget. If an employee fails the drug test, he/she must attend a rehab program or face disciplinary action or discharge.

Legislative Outcome: Passed House 79-37-3 on Mar/2/12; State Rep. Greg Steube voted YES; Passed Senate 26-14-0 on Mar/9/12; Signed by Governor Rick Scott on Mar/19/12

Source: ACLU Analysis of Florida legislative voting record HB 1205 Mar 2, 2012

Matt Gaetz: Require random, mandatory drug testing of state employees

HB 1205: Requires drug testing to be conducted within each state agency's appropriation; authorizes agencies within state government to require employees to submit to periodic random drug testing.

Analysis by ACLU Florida: The legislature took it upon itself to expand the Drug-Free Workplace Program to mandate random, suspicionless drug testing for state employees on a rotating basis. Each state agency can choose whether to participate in the program as it will have to find the funds to do so, i.e. pay for the drug tests, in its current allotted budget. If an employee fails the drug test, he/she must attend a rehab program or face disciplinary action or discharge.

Legislative Outcome: Passed House 79-37-3 on Mar/2/12; State Rep. Matt Gaetz voted YES; Passed Senate 26-14-0 on Mar/9/12; Signed by Governor Rick Scott on Mar/19/12

Source: ACLU Analysis of Florida legislative voting record HB 1205 Mar 2, 2012

Mike Haridopolos: Require random, mandatory drug testing of state employees

HB 1205: Requires drug testing to be conducted within each state agency's appropriation; authorizes agencies within state government to require employees to submit to periodic random drug testing.

Analysis by ACLU Florida: The legislature took it upon itself to expand the Drug-Free Workplace Program to mandate random, suspicionless drug testing for state employees on a rotating basis. Each state agency can choose whether to participate in the program as it will have to find the funds to do so, i.e. pay for the drug tests, in its current allotted budget. If an employee fails the drug test, he/she must attend a rehab program or face disciplinary action or discharge.

Legislative Outcome: Passed House 79-37-3 on Mar/2/12; Passed Senate 26-14-0 on Mar/9/12; State Senator Mike Haridopolos voted YES: Signed by Governor Rick Scott on Mar/19/12

Source: ACLU Analysis of Florida legislative voting record HB 1205 Mar 9, 2012

Rick Scott: Require random, mandatory drug testing of state employees

HB 1205: Requires drug testing to be conducted within each state agency's appropriation; authorizes agencies within state government to require employees to submit to periodic random drug testing.

Analysis by ACLU Florida: The legislature took it upon itself to expand the Drug-Free Workplace Program to mandate random, suspicionless drug testing for state employees on a rotating basis. Each state agency can choose whether to participate in the program as it will have to find the funds to do so, i.e. pay for the drug tests, in its current allotted budget. If an employee fails the drug test, he/she must attend a rehab program or face disciplinary action or discharge.

Legislative Outcome: Passed House 79-37-3 on Mar/2/12; Passed Senate 26-14-0 on Mar/9/12; Signed by Governor Rick Scott on Mar/19/12

Source: ACLU Analysis of Florida legislative voting record HB 1205 Mar 19, 2012

ACLU: Penalties for fentanyl cause prison overcrowding

SB1: To increase penalties for drug trafficking violations, drug possession violations, and aggravated funding of drug trafficking when the drug involved in the offense is a fentanyl-related compound.

ACLU Ohio in opposition (Aug. 1, 2018): The ACLU of Ohio is opposed to SB 1, as it punishes drug addiction while failing to meaningfully effect the overall problem of fentanyl use, abuse, possession, and trafficking. The direct result of SB 1 would be more people--low level addicts and large scale traffickers--in Ohio's prisons for longer periods of time, significantly burdening the already overcapacity prison system in an unproductive way. The bill focuses on punishment and conviction instead of treatment and rehabilitation.

Legislative Summary: Passed Senate 31-1-1 on Jun/27/18; passed House 82-12-5 on Jun/27/18; signed by Governor John Kasich on Aug/1/18.

Source: ACLU on Ohio State Legislature voting records SB 1 Aug 1, 2018

Frank LaRose: Increase penalties for trafficking or possession of fentanyl

SB1: To increase penalties for drug trafficking violations, drug possession violations, and aggravated funding of drug trafficking when the drug involved in the offense is a fentanyl-related compound.

ACLU Ohio in opposition (Aug. 1, 2018): The ACLU of Ohio is opposed to SB 1, as it punishes drug addiction while failing to meaningfully effect the overall problem of fentanyl use, abuse, possession, and trafficking. The direct result of SB 1 would be more people--low level addicts and large scale traffickers--in Ohio's prisons for longer periods of time, significantly burdening the already overcapacity prison system in an unproductive way. The bill focuses on punishment and conviction instead of treatment and rehabilitation.

Legislative Summary: Passed Senate 31-1-1 on Jun/27/18; Sen. Frank LaRose was primary sponsor and voted YES; passed House 82-12-5 on Jun/27/18; signed by Governor John Kasich on Aug/1/18.

Source: ACLU on Ohio State Legislature voting records SB 1 Jun 27, 2018

Joe Schiavoni: Increase penalties for trafficking or possession of fentanyl

SB1: To increase penalties for drug trafficking violations, drug possession violations, and aggravated funding of drug trafficking when the drug involved in the offense is a fentanyl-related compound.

ACLU Ohio in opposition (Aug. 1, 2018): The ACLU of Ohio is opposed to SB 1, as it punishes drug addiction while failing to meaningfully effect the overall problem of fentanyl use, abuse, possession, and trafficking. The direct result of SB 1 would be more people--low level addicts and large scale traffickers--in Ohio's prisons for longer periods of time, significantly burdening the already overcapacity prison system in an unproductive way. The bill focuses on punishment and conviction instead of treatment and rehabilitation.

Legislative Summary: Passed Senate 31-1-1 on Jun/27/18; Sen. Joe Schiavoni voted YES; passed House 82-12-5 on Jun/27/18; signed by Governor John Kasich on Aug/1/18.

Source: ACLU on Ohio State Legislature voting records SB 1 Jun 27, 2018

John Kasich: Increase penalties for trafficking or possession of fentanyl

SB1: To increase penalties for drug trafficking violations, drug possession violations, and aggravated funding of drug trafficking when the drug involved in the offense is a fentanyl-related compound.

ACLU Ohio in opposition (Aug. 1, 2018): The ACLU of Ohio is opposed to SB 1, as it punishes drug addiction while failing to meaningfully effect the overall problem of fentanyl use, abuse, possession, and trafficking. The direct result of SB 1 would be more people--low level addicts and large scale traffickers--in Ohio's prisons for longer periods of time, significantly burdening the already overcapacity prison system in an unproductive way. The bill focuses on punishment and conviction instead of treatment and rehabilitation.

Legislative Summary: Passed Senate 31-1-1 on Jun/27/18; passed House 82-12-5 on Jun/27/18; signed by Governor John Kasich on Aug/1/18.

Source: ACLU on Ohio State Legislature voting records SB 1 Aug 1, 2018

Matt Dolan: Increase penalties for trafficking or possession of fentanyl

SB1: To increase penalties for drug trafficking violations, drug possession violations, and aggravated funding of drug trafficking when the drug involved in the offense is a fentanyl-related compound.

ACLU Ohio in opposition (Aug. 1, 2018): The ACLU of Ohio is opposed to SB 1, as it punishes drug addiction while failing to meaningfully effect the overall problem of fentanyl use, abuse, possession, and trafficking. The direct result of SB 1 would be more people--low level addicts and large scale traffickers--in Ohio's prisons for longer periods of time, significantly burdening the already overcapacity prison system in an unproductive way. The bill focuses on punishment and conviction instead of treatment and rehabilitation.

Legislative Summary: Passed Senate 31-1-1 on Jun/27/18; Sen. Matt Dolan voted YES; passed House 82-12-5 on Jun/27/18; signed by Governor John Kasich on Aug/1/18.

Source: ACLU on Ohio State Legislature voting records SB 1 Jun 27, 2018

Troy Balderson: Increase penalties for trafficking or possession of fentanyl

SB1: To increase penalties for drug trafficking violations, drug possession violations, and aggravated funding of drug trafficking when the drug involved in the offense is a fentanyl-related compound.

ACLU Ohio in opposition (Aug. 1, 2018): The ACLU of Ohio is opposed to SB 1, as it punishes drug addiction while failing to meaningfully effect the overall problem of fentanyl use, abuse, possession, and trafficking. The direct result of SB 1 would be more people--low level addicts and large scale traffickers--in Ohio's prisons for longer periods of time, significantly burdening the already overcapacity prison system in an unproductive way. The bill focuses on punishment and conviction instead of treatment and rehabilitation.

Legislative Summary: Passed Senate 31-1-1 on Jun/27/18; Sen. Troy Balderson voted YES; passed House 82-12-5 on Jun/27/18; signed by Governor John Kasich on Aug/1/18.

Source: ACLU on Ohio State Legislature voting records SB 1 Jun 27, 2018

  • The above quotations are from ACLU congressional voting recommendations.
  • Click here for definitions & background information on Drugs.
  • Click here for other issues (main summary page).
  • Click here for more quotes by ACLU on Drugs.
2016 Presidential contenders on Drugs:
  Republicans:
Gov.Jeb Bush(FL)
Dr.Ben Carson(MD)
Gov.Chris Christie(NJ)
Sen.Ted Cruz(TX)
Carly Fiorina(CA)
Gov.Jim Gilmore(VA)
Sen.Lindsey Graham(SC)
Gov.Mike Huckabee(AR)
Gov.Bobby Jindal(LA)
Gov.John Kasich(OH)
Gov.Sarah Palin(AK)
Gov.George Pataki(NY)
Sen.Rand Paul(KY)
Gov.Rick Perry(TX)
Sen.Rob Portman(OH)
Sen.Marco Rubio(FL)
Sen.Rick Santorum(PA)
Donald Trump(NY)
Gov.Scott Walker(WI)
Democrats:
Gov.Lincoln Chafee(RI)
Secy.Hillary Clinton(NY)
V.P.Joe Biden(DE)
Gov.Martin O`Malley(MD)
Sen.Bernie Sanders(VT)
Sen.Elizabeth Warren(MA)
Sen.Jim Webb(VA)

2016 Third Party Candidates:
Gov.Gary Johnson(L-NM)
Roseanne Barr(PF-HI)
Robert Steele(L-NY)
Dr.Jill Stein(G,MA)
Please consider a donation to OnTheIssues.org!
Click for details -- or send donations to:
1770 Mass Ave. #630, Cambridge MA 02140
E-mail: submit@OnTheIssues.org
(We rely on your support!)

Page last updated: Feb 16, 2024