Bill Schuette (R): Ban, except for incest, rape, & life of the mother. Enforce state prohibitions.
Gretchen Whitmer (D): Legal. End 24-hour waiting period & pre-Roe ban.
Q: Contraception: Allow employers to withhold contraceptive coverage from employees if disagree with it morally? Stance on related family planning funding?
Schuette: Yes. Led lawsuit opposing employer mandate to provide contraceptive coverage. Views as attack on religious liberty--and about abortion-inducing drugs, not birth control.
Whitmer: No. Require insurance companies to cover contraceptives. Restore low-income family planning funds.
Q: Allow Planned Parenthood public funds for non-abortion health care?
Schuette: No. Joined lawsuit to prohibit Planned Parenthood from receiving funding.
Whitmer): Yes. Restore funding so can provide screenings and checkups, contraception, and maternity care.
John James (R): Ban, with an exception for the life of the mother--but not for rape or incest.
Debbie Stabenow (D): Legal. Says has to be a woman's choice.
Q: Let employers withhold contraceptive coverage from employees if disagree with it morally?
John James (R): No public statement found.
Debbie Stabenow (D): No. Co-sponsored bill to protect healthcare benefits, including contraceptive coverage.
Q: Let Planned Parenthood receive public funds for non-abortion healthcare?
John James (R): "Supports efforts to defund abortion providers like Planned Parenthood."
Debbie Stabenow (D): Defunding Planned Parenthood would keep countless women who rely on Medicaid from getting healthcare. They're often the only safety net alternative.
BUSH: I'm going to pick a vice president who can be the president. I'll pick judges who strictly interpret the constitution and not use the bench as a way to legislate. And I will work to keep the Republican Party pro-life.
FORBES: It's a typical hedge. Where's the pledge, not a hedge? Vagaries aren't going to work. We need something specific.
BUSH: I will have a vice president who can become the president. That's the test, Steve. I will have a vice president that agrees with my policy. I'm going to have a vice president that likes me. I can't be any more clear -- you may not like the answer, but that's my answer.
Legislative Outcome: Sen. Whitmer voted NAY; passed Senate 29-8-1, Sept. 21; passed House 75-34-0, Sept. 28; signed by Gov. Snyder, Oct. 11
When she told her personal story of being raped more than 20 years ago during a 2013 speech on the Senate floor to illustrate her opposition to a bill that would require people to buy an additional rider to their insurance to get an abortion covered, Whitmer got national attention and a stronger voice on issues surrounding women's health concerns.
Bill Schuette (R): Ban, except for incest, rape, & life of the mother. Enforce state prohibitions.
Gretchen Whitmer (D): Legal. End 24-hour waiting period & pre-Roe ban, protect in state law.
Q: Contraception: Allow employers to withhold contraceptive coverage from employees if disagree with it morally? Stance on related family planning funding?
Schuette: Yes. Views as attack on religious liberty.
Whitmer: No. "We've seen attack after attack" on reproductive healthcare. Require insurance companies to cover contraceptives. Restore low-income family planning funds.
Q: Allow Planned Parenthood public funds for non-abortion health care?
Schuette: No. Joined lawsuit to prohibit Planned Parenthood from receiving funding.
Whitmer): Yes. Restore funding so can provide screenings and checkups, contraception, and maternity care.
Bergman: When the life of the mother is at risk based on her decision.
John James (R): Ban, with an exception for the life of the mother--but not for rape or incest.
Debbie Stabenow (D): Legal. Says has to be a woman's choice.
Q: Let employers withhold contraceptive coverage from employees if disagree with it morally?
John James (R): No public statement found.
Debbie Stabenow (D): No. Co-sponsored bill to protect healthcare benefits, including contraceptive coverage.
Q: Let Planned Parenthood receive public funds for non-abortion healthcare?
John James (R): "Supports efforts to defund abortion providers like Planned Parenthood."
Debbie Stabenow (D): Defunding Planned Parenthood would keep countless women who rely on Medicaid from getting healthcare. They're often the only safety net alternative.
Legislative Outcome: Sen. Moolenaar voted YEA; passed Senate 29-8-1, Sept. 21; passed House 75-34-0, Sept. 28; signed by Gov. Snyder, Oct. 11
A: Support.
Q: What about federal funding for Planned Parenthood? And for abortion services in general?
A: I support funding for Planned Parenthood and funding for abortion services for poorer women in general. I would also advocate for more sex education and contraceptive availability.
Bishop: Strongly Agree
Q: Should abortion be allowed under extenuating circumstances? If so, what circumstances?
Bishop: I am pro-life with the only exception being that of the life of the mother.
Legislative Outcome: Rep. Tlaib voted NAY; passed Senate 29-8-1, Sept. 21; passed House 75-34-0, Sept. 28; signed by Gov. Snyder, Oct. 11
SB 160 prohibits partial-birth abortion except when necessary to protect the life of the mother. HB 4110 makes performing a partial-birth abortion or assisting in the procedure a felony. A woman who undergoes the procedure would not face criminal charges
The governor did sign highly controversial legislation to restrict abortion that's likely to shut down providers. But that wasn't good enough for RTL. They saw an opportunity with GOP majorities in the House and Senate. So they launched a petition drive for the abortion insurance ban, which, it should be noted, is an interesting interpretation of free market principles. After collecting more than 300,000 signatures, the measure went before the Legislature and passed this month. It cuts the governor completely out of the process--his signature isn't required; this is now the law of the land.
Legislative Outcome: Passed Senate 29-8-1, Sept. 21; passed House 75-34-0, Sept. 28; signed by Gov. Snyder, Oct. 11
BUSH: I'm going to pick a vice president who can be the president. I'll pick judges who strictly interpret the constitution and not use the bench as a way to legislate. And I will work to keep the Republican Party pro-life.
FORBES: It's a typical hedge. Where's the pledge, not a hedge? Vagaries aren't going to work. We need something specific.
BUSH: I will have a vice president who can become the president. That's the test, Steve. I will have a vice president that agrees with my policy. I'm going to have a vice president that likes me. I can't be any more clear -- you may not like the answer, but that's my answer.
In August 2012, Bloomberg reported that the 2012 Republican platform "also proposes a constitutional amendment to ban abortion without stipulating any exceptions for ending pregnancies caused by rape or to save a woman's life."
"Tudor Dixon is a strong pro-life leader who possesses the ability to lead Michigan towards being a life-affirming state. Right to Life of MI PAC is excited to work towards the election of Tudor Dixon as Michigan's next governor." - Paul Miller, chairman of Right to Life of Michigan's PAC board.
GOV. KRISTI NOEM (R-SD): I think we'll continue to have those debates on how we can support these mothers and what it means to really make sure that we're not prosecuting mothers ever in a situation like this when it comes to abortion, that it will always be focused towards those doctors who knowingly break the law to perform abortions in our state.
Whitmer shot back: "None of what she said is true." The two were clashing over what's known as Proposal 3, which would scrap Michigan's 1931 law banning abortion. In the wake of the US Supreme Court overturning Roe v. Wade, Whitmer sued to block the enforcement of the state's 1931 abortion ban, and she has backed Proposal 3.
Proposal 3's opponents say it would nullify virtually all existing guardrails. "You cannot trust her on this issue. If you want to protect Roe v. Wade rights, vote yes on 3," Whitmer said.
Whitmer shot back: "None of what she said is true." The two were clashing over what's known as Proposal 3--a measure placed on the ballot after a petition drive seeking to amend the state's constitution to scrap Michigan's 1931 law banning abortion with no exceptions for cases of rape and incest. That law, which had long been dormant, was revived after the Supreme Court's decision overturning Roe v. Wade before a judge ruled the law unconstitutional in September.
Associated Press summary April 5, 2023: A near-century old abortion ban that fueled one of the largest ballot drives in Michigan history was repealed by Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, just months after voters enshrined abortion rights in the state's constitution.
Legislative Outcome: Passed Senate 20-18-0 on Mar/8/23; passed House 56-52-2 on Mar/22/23; Signed by Gov. Gretchen Whitmer on Apr/11/23.
Associated Press summary April 5, 2023: A near-century old abortion ban that fueled one of the largest ballot drives in Michigan history was repealed by Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, just months after voters enshrined abortion rights in the state's constitution.
Legislative Outcome: Passed Senate 20-18-0 on Mar/8/23; State Sen. Kristen McDonald Rivet sponsored and voted YES; passed House 56-52-2 on Mar/22/23; Signed by Gov. Gretchen Whitmer on Apr/11/23.
Summary by LiveAction .org, Jun 10, 2016Michigan Republican Governor Rick Snyder signed HB 4787 and HB 4380 into law, a pair of bills that now protect women in the state from being coerced into having abortions. One bill makes it a felony punishable by prison time to stalk or assault a pregnant woman for the purpose of pressuring her into an abortion.
Legislative Outcome: Passed House 65-43-3 on Mar/24/16; State Rep. Aric Nesbitt voted YES; passed Senate 26-11-0 on May/25/16; signed by Governor Rick Snyder on Jun/8/2016
Summary by LiveAction .org, Jun 10, 2016Michigan Republican Governor Rick Snyder signed HB 4787 and HB 4380 into law, a pair of bills that now protect women in the state from being coerced into having abortions. One bill makes it a felony punishable by prison time to stalk or assault a pregnant woman for the purpose of pressuring her into an abortion.
Legislative Outcome: Passed House 65-43-3 on Mar/24/16; passed Senate 26-11-0 on May/25/16; signed by Governor Rick Snyder on Jun/8/2016
Summary by LiveAction .org, Jun 10, 2016Michigan Republican Governor Rick Snyder signed HB 4787 and HB 4380 into law, a pair of bills that now protect women in the state from being coerced into having abortions. One bill makes it a felony punishable by prison time to stalk or assault a pregnant woman for the purpose of pressuring her into an abortion.
Legislative Outcome: Passed House 65-43-3 on Mar/24/16; State Rep. Thomas Barrett voted YES; State Rep. passed Senate 26-11-0 on May/25/16; signed by Governor Rick Snyder on Jun/8/2016
Summary by LiveAction .org, Jun 10, 2016Michigan Republican Governor Rick Snyder signed HB 4787 and HB 4380 into law, a pair of bills that now protect women in the state from being coerced into having abortions. One bill makes it a felony punishable by prison time to stalk or assault a pregnant woman for the purpose of pressuring her into an abortion.
Legislative Outcome: Passed House 65-43-3 on Mar/24/16; State Rep. Tom Leonard voted YES; passed Senate 26-11-0 on May/25/16; signed by Governor Rick Snyder on Jun/8/2016
Legislative Outcome: Aric Nesbitt voted YEA; passed Senate 29-8-1, Sept. 21; passed House 75-34-0, Sept. 28; signed by Gov. Snyder, Oct. 11
Associated Press summary April 5, 2023: A near-century old abortion ban that fueled one of the largest ballot drives in Michigan history was repealed by Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, just months after voters enshrined abortion rights in the state's constitution.
Legislative Outcome: Passed Senate 20-18-0 on Mar/8/23; Aric Nesbitt voted NO; passed House 56-52-2 on Mar/22/23; Signed by Gov. Gretchen Whitmer on Apr/11/23.
A: strongly support
A: Support; every woman deserves to have access to safe abortions.
| |||
| 2026 Senate and Gubernatorial contenders on Abortion: | |||
|
2026 Senatorial debates:
- AK - AL - AR - CO - DE - FL - GA - IA - ID - IL - - KS - KY - LA - MA - ME - MI - MN - MS - MT - NC - NH - NJ - NM - - OH - OK - OR - RI - SC - SD - TN - VA - WV - WY - |
2026 Gubernatorial debates:
- AK - AL - AR - AZ - CA - CO - CT - FL - GA - HI - IA - ID - IL - - KS - MA - MD - ME - MI - MN - NE - NH - NJ - NM - NV - NY - - OH - OK - OR - PA - RI - SC - SD - TN - TX - VA - VT - WI - WY - | ||
|
Please consider a donation to OnTheIssues.org!
Click for details -- or send donations to: 1770 Mass Ave. #630, Cambridge MA 02140 E-mail: submit@OnTheIssues.org (We rely on your support!) | |||