Democratic Primary Debate at The Citadel, sponsored by YouTube and CNN: on Energy & Oil


Barack Obama: Explore nuclear power as part of alternative energy mix

Q: What about nuclear power as an alternative energy source?

A: I actually think that we should explore nuclear power as part of the energy mix. There are no silver bullets to this issue. We have to develop solar. I have proposed drastically increasing fuel efficiency standards on cars, an aggressive cap on the amount of greenhouse gases that can be emitted. But we're going to have to try a series of different approaches.

Source: 2007 YouTube Democratic Primary debate, Charleston SC Jul 23, 2007

Barack Obama: Cheney met environmentalists once; but Big Oil 40 times

The reason [our energy policy] doesn't change--you can take a look at how Dick Cheney did his energy policy. He met with environmental groups once. He met with renewable energy folks once. And then he met with oil and gas companies 40 times. And that's how they put together our energy policy. We've got to put the national interests ahead of special interests, and that's what I'll do as president of the United States.
Source: 2007 YouTube Democratic Primary debate, Charleston SC Jul 23, 2007

Chris Dodd: Raise standard to 50 mpg by 2017; make federal fleet hybrids

Q: How do you get Americans to conserve?

A: There are a number of things. The 50-mile-per-gallon standard is something I've advocated by 2017, that I would push hard for. Entire fleet of federal automobiles would be hybrids or electric automobiles, so we reduce even further out consumption. I myself drive a hybrid. But I believe I'm the only candidate here, along with Al Gore, who's called for a corporate carbon tax.

Source: 2007 YouTube Democratic Primary debate, Charleston SC Jul 23, 2007

Chris Dodd: Impose corporate carbon tax; need price incentives for GHGs

[I support a] corporate carbon tax. You've got to tax polluters. You've got to separate the price differential so that we can move away from fossil fuels that do so much damage to our environment, to our economy, to our future, to jobs in this country. Until you deal with the issue of price, until you impose a corporate carbon tax, we will never get away from fossil fuels. It's the only way this can be achieved. You have to advocate that if you're serious about global warming.
Source: 2007 YouTube Democratic Primary debate, Charleston SC Jul 23, 2007

Chris Dodd: FactCheck: Two other candidates also call for carbon taxes

Chris Dodd was rhetorically accurate but intellectually disingenuous when he said, "I believe I'm the only candidate here, along with Al Gore, who's called for a corporate carbon tax. You've got to tax polluters."

Dodd is the only candidate to call for a "corporate carbon tax," and indeed, Al Gore has advocated the same, though he often refers to it as a "pollution tax." But two other candidates offer similar plans. Both Richardson and Edwards have proposed some form of carbon permitting by which companies would have to apply and pay a fee for the right to emit carbon pollutants. It is worth noting that all three candidates have also called for a reduction in greenhouse emissions of at least 80% below 1990 levels by 2050.

Source: FactCheck.org on 2007 YouTube Democratic Primary debate Jul 23, 2007

Dennis Kucinich: Current approach to energy results in war for oil

Q: What about global warming?

A: We have to understand the connection between global warring and global warming. Because when we start talking about wars for oil, we're essentially keeping the same approach to energy. We need to move away from reliance on oil and coal and toward reliance on wind and solar. That's the basis of my WGA, Works Green Administration, where we take an entirely new approach to organize the entire country around sustainability, around conservation.

Q: Are your fellow candidates green enough?

A: No. If you support, for example, in Iraq, if you say that Iraq should privatize its oil for the US oil companies, then what you're doing is you're continuing a commitment to use more oil. If you believe that all options should be put on the table with respect to Iran, that's about oil. So we need to move away from reliance on oil. And that's really connected to our defense policy, and I'm the one who gets the connection.

Source: 2007 YouTube Democratic Primary debate, Charleston SC Jul 23, 2007

Hillary Clinton: End Big Oil tax break; $50 billion for strategic energy fund

I have proposed a strategic energy fund that I would fund by taking away the tax break for the oil companies, which have gotten much greater under Bush and Cheney. And we could spend about $50 billion doing what America does best. It's time we start acting like Americans again. We can solve these problems if we focus on innovation and technology. Alternative forms of energy are important. So is fuel efficiency for cars and so is energy efficiency for buildings.
Source: 2007 YouTube Democratic Primary debate, Charleston SC Jul 23, 2007

Hillary Clinton: Agnostic about nuclear power until waste & cost issue solved

Q: What about nuclear power as an alternative energy source?

A: I'm agnostic about nuclear power. Until we figure out what we're going to do with the waste and the cost, it's very hard to see nuclear as a part of our future. But that's where American technology comes in. Let's figure out what we're going to do about the waste and the cost if we think nuclear should be a part of the solution.

Source: 2007 YouTube Democratic Primary debate, Charleston SC Jul 23, 2007

Hillary Clinton: FactCheck: There was no Big Oil tax break under Bush-Cheney

Clinton wrongly claimed that the Bush-Cheney administration had increased tax breaks for the oil industry:
CLINTON: First of all, I have proposed a strategic energy fund that I would fund by taking away the tax break for the oil companies, which have gotten much greater under Bush and Cheney.
Actually, the highly publicized energy bill the president signed in 2005 raised taxes slightly on the oil industry as a whole. The Energy Policy Act of 2005 provided about $2.6 billion of tax cuts for the oil and gas industry, plus $2.9 billion of tax increases, for a net tax increase on the industry of nearly $300 million over 11 years.

It's true that many generous subsidies were proposed and debated, but those were stripped out before the bill was passed. The final bill contained $14.3 billion in tax breaks, but the bulk of the cuts went to electric utilities, and nuclear, and also to alternative fuels research and subsidies for energy-efficiency--not to the oil industry.

Source: FactCheck.org on 2007 YouTube Democratic Primary debate Jul 23, 2007

John Edwards: No new nuclear power plants; no liquified coal either

Q: What about nuclear power as an alternative energy source?

A: Wind, solar, cellulose-based biofuels are the way we need to go. I do not favor nuclear power. We haven't built a nuclear power plant in decades in this country. There is a reason for that. The reason is it is extremely costly. It takes an enormous amount of time to get one planned, developed and built. And we still don't have a safe way to dispose of the nuclear waste. It is a huge problem for America over the long term. I also don't believe we should liquefy coal. The last thing we need is another carbon-based fuel in America. We need to find fuels that are in fact renewable, clean, and will allow us to address directly the question that has been raised, which is the issue of global warming, which I believe is a crisis.

Source: 2007 YouTube Democratic Primary debate, Charleston SC Jul 23, 2007

  • The above quotations are from 2007 Democratic Primary Debate at The Citadel, in Charleston, South Carolina, July 23, 2007, sponsored by YouTube and CNN.
  • Click here for definitions & background information on Energy & Oil.
  • Click here for more quotes by Barack Obama on Energy & Oil.
  • Click here for more quotes by Hillary Clinton on Energy & Oil.
2008 Presidential contenders on Energy & Oil:
Republicans:
Chmn.John Cox
Mayor Rudy Giuliani
Gov.Mike Huckabee
Rep.Duncan Hunter
Sen.John McCain
Rep.Ron Paul
Gov.Mitt Romney
Sen.Fred Thompson
Democrats:
Sen.Hillary Clinton
Sen.John Edwards
Sen.Mike Gravel
Rep.Dennis Kucinich
Sen.Barack Obama
Third Parties:
Green: Rep.Cynthia McKinney
Socialist: Brian Moore
Independent: Mayor Mike Bloomberg
Please consider a donation to OnTheIssues.org!
Click for details -- or send donations to:
1770 Mass Ave. #630, Cambridge MA 02140
E-mail: submit@OnTheIssues.org
(We rely on your support!)